Can't return kulemak's finger.

Tried the fight multiple times. Only get option to take finger. Abyss progression is pretty much bricked.

Same when using an Xbox Controller, 2 invitations both wasted.

I also had this issue but when i pressed "x" (PS5 console) to take the finger, it gave me another prompt, in this case I was able to select either option...not sure if that worked for others. I initially tried to relog, reconnect, also messed around with the controls and bindings but i eventually gave up and pressed X, but it gave me another option after that.

Same issue still happening on Xbox. Only option is to take finger. If you press and hold the interact button you can scroll to choose either option. Take finger or return finger! Hope this helps!

You need to click on one of the different abyssal leaders sitting at the end of the hall after beating kulemak them you will fight again. Do this 3 times and you sbould get option to return the finger.